Brad Paisley-LL Cool J draw ire with song on bias
Country singer Brad Paisley says he was trying to foster an open
discussion of race relations when he collaborated with rapper LL Cool J
on "Accidental Racist."
The new song about racial perceptions has drawn ire
from both the country and urban music worlds after its wide release
this week. Paisley, the singer-songwriter known for his white cowboy hat
and virtuoso guitar work, gave his first interview Tuesday since the
hubbub began on "The Ellen DeGeneres Show" after briefly addressing the
debate Monday night on Twitter.
"I felt like when we were writing this song, it
wasn't necessarily up to the media and I don't really trust Hollywood
... or talk radio or anything like that to sort of deal with that
anymore," Paisley said on the show. "I think it's music's turn to have
the conversation."
The song appears on Paisley's new self-produced
album "Wheelhouse," released Tuesday. It's his most ambitious album so
far and the progressive message of "Accidental Racist" is in line with
opinions the 40-year-old West Virginia-born singer has expressed before
in interviews and songs.
Of the album, Paisley wrote on Twitter, "I hope it
triggers emotions," and says he wouldn't change a thing about it: "This
is a record meant to be FAR from easy listening. But fun. Like life.
Have a ball, ya'll."
At its heart, "Accidental Racist" is about how
cultural symbols favored by whites and blacks - the fashion choice of
wearing Confederate flags or baggy pants, for instance - come loaded
with meaning.
It's not a new discussion. Though race relations have evolved over the decades, cultural symbols continue to color perceptions.
Paisley uses the Confederate flag as an example in
the song, noting whites are "caught between Southern pride and Southern
blame" 150 years after the end of the Civil War.
"I try to put myself in your shoes and that's a
good place to begin," Paisley sings, "but it ain't like I can walk a
mile in someone else's skin/Because I'm a white man livin' in the
southland/Just like you I'm more than what it seems/I'm proud of where
I'm from/But not everything we've done/It ain't like you and me can
rewrite history/Our generation didn't start this nation/We're still
paying for mistakes that a bunch of folks made long before we came."
Paisley was unavailable for an interview and LL
Cool J's publicist did not immediately respond to messages. The
45-year-old rapper, who elevated himself from a teen sensation on the
streets of Queens to an American cultural icon as a personality and
actor on shows like CBS's "NCIS: Los Angeles," provides the response to
Paisley's meditations.
He kicks off his portion of the song "Dear, Mr.
White Man, I wish you understood what the world was really like living
in the hood." Later in the song he raps, "I guess we're both guilty of
judging the cover not the book/I'd love to buy you a beer, conversate
and clear the air/But I see that red flag and I think you wish I wasn't
here."
Later he and Paisley enter a call and response
portion of the song where LL Cool J raps in part: "If you don't judge my
'do rag, I won't judge your red flag. ... If you don't judge my gold
chains, I'll forget the iron chains ... Can't rewrite history, baby ...
let bygones be bygones ... Rest in peace, Robert E. Lee, I got to thank
Abraham Lincoln for freeing me ... ."
"One of my favorite lines in the song is he says 'I
think the relationship between the Mason-Dixon needs some fixin','"
Paisley told DeGeneres. "Leave it to a rapper to put it so simply and so
beautifully."
Not all the good people of the blogosphere and Twitter world were as taken, though, and comedians were weighing in as well.
Demetria Irwin of black culture blog The Grio
wrote, "'Accidental Racist' is the worst song in the history of music,"
then broke it down line by line.
Comedian Patton Oswalt tweeted: "I can't wait for
Brad Paisley & LL Cool J's next single: "Whoopsy Daisy, Holocaust,
My Bad""
Even the usually open-armed Ahmir "Questlove"
Thompson of The Roots seemed taken aback as he tweeted: "Just heard the
"Accidental Racist" man that Weird Al is amazing."
A little later, he compared the reaction to
"Accidental Racist" to the recent backlash over Rick Ross' contribution
to the Rocko song "O.U.E.N.O," which brought an apology after detractors
accused him of glorifying date rape.
"All the "OUENO" weigher ins....i expect "Accidental Racist" to get equal amount of discussion & dialogue," he wrote.
That it did. Paisley told DeGeneres that was the point.
"Make up your own mind," he said. "That's fine. You can throw things at me. I'm all right."